Cheese is essential!
And we have new meat and dairy items too! Read more below!
You are welcome to come to the store to shop in person*, or call to place a curbside pickup.
We are open during our regular business hours:
Wed & Thurs: 11am - 6pm
Fri & Sat: 10am - 7pm
Sun: 10am - 4pm
Free delivery is available within a 5-mile radius of the store after hours for our customers under quarantine
*If shopping in person, please respect our rules of one person in the shop at one time, and please wear the disposable gloves that we will provide for you, thank you!
NEW: FRESH GROUND MEAT FROM DELLAPIETRA'S!
We are thrilled to be able to expand our affiliation with gourmet butcher Dellapietra's of Brooklyn.
We have restocked our inventory of 85-day dry aged NY Strip and Double Cut Ribeye Steaks, which are currently available frozen at the store.
Rob at Dellapietra's is offering us his gourmet restaurant-quality, prime ground meats (no antibiotics, no hormones): 80/20 organic choice ground beef, 90/10 ground turkey and 90/10 ground chicken.
Ground meats will be available fresh, in 10lb packages, via PRE-ORDER ONLY. Call the store during business hours to place your order, and pick up fresh - not frozen - the following Wednesday.
Ground meats can be portioned out and frozen for burgers, sauces, tacos, chilis … why not go in on a 10lb package and share with your neighbors!
Call 914-764-1525 to place your ground meat order!
NEW: MILK FROM ARETHUSA FARM DAIRY!
We have brought in 1/2-gallons of Whole Milk from our friends at Arethusa Farm Dairy in Litchfield, CT. These are now available in the store, along with their delicious ice cream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Coffee and Mint Chocolate Chip.
In addition, we will be taking weekly orders for 1/2 gallons of Whole, 2% Lowfat and Skim Milk. Orders must be received by Sunday 3pm; delivery from the farm arrives at our store every Thursday.
Call 914-764-1525 to place your milk pre-order!
NEW: HIGHLANDER FROM JASPER HILL FARM!
We continue to receive fresh deliveries of all of your favorite cheeses, and we are welcoming some new additions to our counter, too!
Say hello to Highlander, an aged, washed rind, raw milk, cow and goat blend from my favorite farm - Jasper Hill in Greensboro VT.
Semi-firm with notes of bacon, macadamia nuts and butter, this is also a wonderful melting cheese.
Why not have a fun raclette night with the family?
Melt Highlander over boiled potatoes with our smoked ham or prosciutto and cornichons on the side. Guaranteed deliciousness!
NEW: CBD OIL FROM LOCALLY BASED oHHo!
Now is definitely the time to seek relief from stress. Michael and I can vouch first-hand that these pure, full spectrum, organically grown, single origin CBD oils have helped us achieve that. The oil reduces inflammation in our shoulders and backs, and takes our anxiety down a notch after a long day - which is sooo welcomed!
We are happy to be able to offer these CDB oils to you, which were developed by our customers who live locally.
Finest quality, organically grown and sustainably sourced. Two different origins offer two distinctive profiles to try. We like them both!
More information is available in the store.
Here are 3 ways for you to enjoy all that Plum Plums Cheese has to offer:
1) Come to the store. We are diligently cleaning throughout the day, and while we would love to give everyone a supportive hug, we will be practicing our social distancing and requesting you to put on disposable gloves. Unfortunately we can't offer our table for dining in, but we will pack your order with a smile for you to take home. It's a nice, safe place to visit!
2) Call us to place a curbside pickup order. We will be happy to meet you at your car. Orders can only be placed when speaking with a human over the phone … no email or text orders please. Call 914-764-1525 and we will strive to get your order completed within a one hour period, or at your requested time later in the day.
3) Call us to request a delivery order. We are offering free delivery within a 5 mile radius of Scotts Corners for any of our customers under quarantine. All orders received during the day will be delivered after 6pm that same day. Call 914-764-1525 to place your order. We will alert you when we arrive at your home and will leave your package at your front door.
This photo of us is from last year - and a reminder that things will return to normal again. Boy, won't we all have fun catching up on our missed celebrations!!!
Michael and I are here to help make this trying time less stressful for you in any way that we can. We continue to replenish our delicious inventory and we plan to remain open without skipping a beat.
If you have a suggestion of other items we can try to source for you, please call us and we will do our best.
Thank you so much for supporting us, and for supporting all the small businesses in our area as best as you can.
And remember … life is great, cheese makes it better!